Sunday, December 19, 2010

Are serotonin boosters neurotoxic?

According to Dr Joseph Glenmullen in Prozac Backlash studies have shown that some serotonin boosters exhibit signs of neurotoxicity. A study on a drug called Redux (abruptly recalled from the market in 1997 because of heart valve damage) examined the possibility of neurotoxicity.

Under the microscope, as they are injured, the axons look "swollen," "irregularly shaped," and "seemingly fragmented." In one study, monkeys treated with the drug for just four days showed evidence of "persistent" and "possibly permanent" damage more than a year later... If the damage is not too severe, the neurons sprout new branches in what literally amounts to a rewiring of the brain.

Prozac Backlash, p. 96.

Those experiments were done with a dose similar to what humans take for 6 months... a year... sometimes a decade or more. The "antipsychotics" (also known as major tranquilizers) fell out of favor once severe, permanent side effects such as tardive dyskinesia were revealed over a span of 20-30 years. Prozac and many SSRIs came into fashion in the 1990s, which means we are just now at the cusp where the long term effects will begin to be revealed. Conveniently, just after the patent expires, but that's a different story. The main problem is that the brain can sustain quite a bit of damage and still function. You can think of it as sort of a buffer or safety margin that has to be consumed until problems show up. However, aging has detrimental effects on the brain as well. This means that damage may be done by drugs earlier in life that won't reveal themselves until later, once the brain starts deteriorating from aging effects.

Studies of Ecstasy [MDMA] have shown that when damaged neurons sprout new branches, the rewiring of the brain is "highly abnormal," a chaotic jumble that does not follow the original pattern. Most alarming, researchers are concerned that the neurotoxicity could cause "increased risk for developing age-related cognitive impairment." Indeed, they are explicit that the "aberant reinnervation [abnormal rewiring of brain cells] such as that seen after MDMA injury may also occur during the course of neurodegenerative diseases [e.g., Parkinson's and Alzheimer's disease]. This is especially worrysome because patient with Alzheimer's type dementia "have significant 5-HT [serotonin] deficits in brain regions implicated in learning and memory" as well as deficits in other neurotransmitters.
Prozac Backlash, pp. 96-97

To be fair, Ecstacy is a serotonin releaser that will cause a sudden release of massive amounts of serotonin. However, most Ecstacy users don't pop pills every day, so it is an acute case vs the chronic case of SSRIs. Dr. Monika Wrona, writing in a June 1997 article published in the National Institude on Drug Abuse Research Monnograph Series, stated that serotonin is "very easily oxidized into a serotonergic neurotoxin." Dr. McCann at NIMH speculated that such damage to the brain caused by serotonin toxicity may be why the effect of the drugs wear off over time.

Regardless of whether it is brain damage from neurotoxicity or simply the brain adapting to the presence of a foreign drug, the before and after pictures are dramatic. Would you take a pill every day for months or years that did this?







Tuesday, December 14, 2010

Will we ever wake up to the deadly risks of happy pills?

Will we ever wake up to the deadly risks of happy pills?

As new research reveals antidepressants raise the danger of heart attacks, the disturbing cost of this modern addiction

The latest study, by Dr Mark Hamer, a public health researcher at University College ­London, shows that people on the older drugs — tricyclic antidepressants — are at far higher risk of cardiovascular disease than those taking the newer class of pills, selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs).

But if I were taking SSRIs, I would not be cheered by the findings. Tricyclics were ­discovered in the Forties and it is only now we have identified these dangerous effects.

Moreover, some SSRI drugs are known to cause serious problems such as stomach bleeding. In addition, the withdrawal symptoms can be so severe that patients may become dependent on them.

Dr Hamer says his findings do not only affect people with depression, because antidepressants are also prescribed to people with back pain, headache, anxiety and sleeping problems.

Last year, according to Dr Hamer’s figures, about 33 million antidepressant prescriptions were dispensed in England.

At some point, surely, there will be no one left to prescribe for. In my view, it’s fast becoming one of the greatest medical scandals of our age.


Tuesday, November 30, 2010

Scientific American: Depression Drugs Affect Personality

Scientific American follows up on the study that showed that antidepressant drugs affect personality.

Experts have long known that the placebo effect explains much of the mood lift patients report after going on antidepressants. This was the case in the new study, published in the journal Archives of General Psychiatry—patients with major depressive disorder who were given a placebo saw their symptoms improve about three quarters as much as those given paroxetine, an antidepressant also known as Paxil. But only the patients who took paroxetine displayed personality changes in two key areas of the widely used five-factor model of personality: they scored lower on neuroticism, the tendency to experience negative emotions such as guilt and anxiety, and they scored higher on extroversion, which includes traits such as talkativeness and assertiveness.

Personality traits are thought to be relatively stable over a person’s life—even the onset of depression, which comes with unusually low moods, should not alter a person’s fundamental traits. Personality can affect a person’s risk for mental illness, however—past research has established neuroticism as a key risk factor for depression, explains Tony Tang of Northwestern University, the lead author of the study. Tang and his colleagues found that the more a patient’s neuroticism dropped while taking paroxetine, the smaller the chance that his or her depression would return after they stopped taking the drug.

The study “proves in an elegant way that antidepressant medications and placebo have different actions in many cases,” says Andrew Leuchter, a depression researcher at the University of California, Los Angeles, who was not a part of the study. “This may explain in part some of the ways that antidepressants have a therapeutic benefit for some patients.”

Yeah, "therapeutic benefits": start an affair, compulsively lie about it, ditch your marriage, have promiscuous sex. Much more beneficial... or just manic if you ask me. Did they ever stop to ask what you would get if you took someone who already pegged the extroversion meter a drug that would further increase extroversion? My answer: mania.


Friday, October 29, 2010

SSRIs may cause personality change --Archives of General Psychiatry (Dec 2009)


Patients taking a SSRI antidepressant to treat depression may experience changes in their personality separate from the alleviation of depressive symptoms, according to a report in the December 2009 issue of Archives of General Psychiatry.

“Patients taking paroxetine reported 6.8 times as much change on neuroticism and 3.5 times as much change on extraversion as placebo patients matched for depression improvement,” the authors write.

The findings provide evidence against a theory known as the state effect hypothesis, which proposes that any personality changes during SSRI treatment occur only as a result of alleviating depressive symptoms, the authors note. Several alternative explanations could be considered. “One possibility is that the biochemical properties of SSRIs directly produce real personality change,” they write. “Furthermore, because neuroticism is an important risk factor that captures much of the genetic vulnerability for major depressive disorder, change in neuroticism (and in neurobiological factors underlying neuroticism) might have contributed to depression improvement.”

Monday, October 4, 2010

Poll: Scientific American readers trust what scientists say about "depression drugs" least, second to only "flu pandemics"

Interesting poll here by the Scientific American: In Science We Trust

The basic point of the article and poll is to see how trustworthy a selection Nature and Scientific American readers thought scientists were in the wake of "climategate" and hyperbolic swine flu epidemic predictions.

The more interesting thing for this blog is how much the respondents trusted scientists in a breakdown of selected subjects.

Flu Pandemics is dead last at 3.19

Depression Drugs is just a few ticks above that at 3.21

And strangely, both pharmaceutical related. Hmm.

I realize that this isn't a scientific poll, but I still find this interesting.



"Antidepressants Under Scrutiny Over Efficacy" --WSJ January 2008

Antidepressants Under Scrutiny over Efficacy -- Wall Street Journal, Jan 2008

More evidence that (surprise, surprise) drug manufacturers attempt to present their products in the best possible light. And why not... if they happen to get called on fraud they just settle for a couple hundred million... peanuts.

A total of 74 studies involving a dozen antidepressants and 12,564 patients were registered with the FDA from 1987 through 2004. The FDA considered 38 of the studies to be positive. All but one of those studies was published, the researchers said.
The other 36 were found to have negative or questionable results by the FDA. Most of those studies -- 22 out of 36 -- weren't published, the researchers found. Of the 14 that were published, the researchers said at least 11 of those studies mischaracterized the results and presented a negative study as positive.

...

Dr. Turner, who once worked at the FDA reviewing data on psychotropic drugs, said the idea for the study was triggered in part by colleagues who questioned the need for further clinical drug trials looking at the effectiveness of antidepressants.

"There is a view that these drugs are effective all the time," he said. "I would say they only work 40% to 50% of the time," based on his reviews of the research at the FDA, "and they would say, 'What are you talking about? I have never seen a negative study.'" Dr. Turner, said he knew from his time with the agency that there were negative studies that hadn't been published.

...

In this week's study, the researchers found that failing to publish negative findings inflated the reported effectiveness of all 12 of the antidepressants studied, which were approved between 1987 and 2004. The researchers used a measurement called effect size. The larger the effect size, the greater the impact of a treatment.

Effexor's estimated effect size was 27% (XR) and 28% in the study. Zoloft 64%. Paxil 40%. Prozac 14%. These are the increased apparent effectiveness of the drug treatments because of the omission of negative reports. You could read this as X% less effective when the positive bias is removed.


Tuesday, September 14, 2010

Stories of the Effuxed. "Effexor kills your marriage" by Rick.

Yet another story about how Effexor causes marital problems. I don't know how this one ended, but if they were talking about side effects then I believe there is a good chance they worked things out. I'll just choose to believe that.

Anyway, here's Rick's story:


For 10 years, my wife and I have enjoyed a wonderful life togther. I LOVE MY WIFE SO MUCH IT MAKES ME CRY AS I WRITE THIS. We were always having fun, incredible sex, a true passion for each other mentally and physically. She was a gift from God. People often commented what a great relationship we had. We would complete each others sentences and at parties would often catch each others eye from across the room and we hated to be apart even for a few minutes. Then after a really bad two years at her new job, she went into depression and had to quit her job. About ten monhts ago, she went on Effexor. Then started a new job. I supported her every step of the way. Then it all started. First the night sweats. Then the weight gain and constipation. Quit the gym. Working rediculous hours. Then the blackouts when she drank alcohol, even in front of friends. FYI, we are both in our 40's, a little old to have drunken blackouts. Then she just seemed to drift away mentally and physically. The only time she will have sex that she enjoys is when she is drunk. If she is sober and I initiate sex, she just looks into space and looks empty inside. The passion in our marriage is almost gone. I have pleaded with her, tried to buy back her sanity with gifts and surprise gestures, tried anything anyone would recommend to get her to see what this drug is doing to her and our marriage. I even stopped drinking to set an example. I tried being harsh, I tried threats, I tried showing more love, doing more around the house, but it has all failed. I even asked her to chose between me and the Effexor and Alcohol...she did not pick me. That hurt. Nothing is working. She can't even shed a tear anymore. Her memory is so bad she forgot the two years of depression and how I was there every day for her. When she tried to defend herself, she makes no sense at all, but feels she is making sense. She just looks at me and says I am the problem. I think her doctor made a huge mistake and it may cost me the women of my dreams. I am so depressed now that I may need to try one of these drugs....definately not Effexor. I just want my wife back. I would give up everything to get her back. Does anyone have any suggestions or similar expeiences? Please!!!! Time is running out for us. I miss my wife. (Wed Oct 11 13:07 2006)


Here is a list my wife and I put together of all the side effects of using Effexor 150mg.

Effexor 150mg problems
Rating: 1=Minor 5=Serious

Tremor = 2
Restless Legs = 4
Constipation = 4
Night Sweats = 3
Texture Problems =3
Sexual Dysfunction = 5
Intimacy problems
Fatigue= 5
Lacking Self Awareness = 4
“Ticks” or other uncontrollable actions = 5
· Finger Nail clicking =5
· Scratching = 5
· Eyebrow pulling = 5
· Face touching = 4
· Nail biting = 5
· Picking at nails = 4
Weight gain = 3
Lack of emotion = 4
Inappropriate behavior = 3
Poor decision making = 4
Inability to prioritize = 4
Dry Mouth = 2
Startled Easily = 4
Warming sensation of the head = 2
Overwhelming Fear of missing a dosage = 5
Alcohol Related Problems = 5
· Memory loss = 4
· Blackouts or Pass outs = 2
· Poor judgment or decision making = 5
· Decrease in Tolerance = 5
· Constant stroking of hair = 4

(Thu Oct 12 9:59 2006)